A Comment On Health Professionals Legal Obligations Dealing With Possible Killers

I don’t get the drift of some of  what is called new legislation here in New York state dealing with a health professionals legal obligation to report on patients who are potential killers. My understanding is if you are practicing medicine properly that was always a given understanding. Whether or not I like the mental health care policies of Governor Cuomo and President Obama, I admit if a patient tells me they are planning to try to shoot Cuomo or Obama, I would feel professionally and ethically obligated to immediately turn that patient into law enforcement  officials, even though I fear the police and FBI are corrupt. However, it has sadly been my experience that even though psychiatrists are taught to do proper mental status exams as medical students, they never do. You are simply supposed to ask a patient if they are planning to kill anyone when doing a proper mental status exam. If the patient says yes and that they are not kidding, than clearly you may be dealing with some type of very serious mental health issue and you certainly have a serious legal issue at hand. However, if the person says no and goes out and kills someone anyway, than it is my position you may very well be dealing with premeditated murder in the first degree.  And of course all of this becomes a really sad and difficult legal issue for everyone involved if a person who kills people was on psychiatric drugs at the time, since these drugs really do set off suicidal and homicidal ideation and intent.  And since there are no biological markers for any of the diagnoses of the psychiatrists, such disorders as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder may not even exist, and it is questionable whether anyone should ever be put on their poisonous arsenal of drugs. -Dr Harold Mandel


The Harold Mandel, MD Natural Mental Health Care Reform Association

About Harold Mandel

After becoming a physician I became interested in Natural Health Care when I discovered that orthodox medicine often does not offer people what they are searching for when they are interested in their optimal health potential. I also developed an interest in working for mental health care reforms when I learned that mental health care human rights abuses are a very serious problem across the United States and internationally. I have devoted a major part of my professional career towards working to improve mental health care. I have founded "The Harold Mandel, MD Natural Mental Health Care Reform Association" and the "Mandel News Service" to help expose and wipe out mental health care human rights abuses while offering natural options for mental health care. Please be advised that unless otherwise stated the positions against psychiatry in this blog are solely based on my opinions. These opinions are not based on scientific studies. The commentaries in this blog are in no manners meant to take the place of medical treatment if such medical treatment is necessary. However, it is my advice to all readers that you should consult with health care providers who are not psychiatrists if you need help with your general health or mental health. And if at anytime psychiatrists force treatment on you I encourage you try to get help from a lawyer who has an interest in helping people fight unwanted psychiatric treatment. Also, please be advised that although reports herein are often very critical of US Department of Justice associated mental health care brutality I am a peace activist and I only support peaceful forms of protest!-Harold Mandel
This entry was posted in Health and wellness, News and politics. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s